Skip to main content
Back to Encyclopedia

Roofing Brands Guide

Compare the top roofing manufacturers. Understand their strengths, product lines, and which brand is best for your needs.

14 brands reviewed

Sort by:
GAF logo

GAF

Founded 1886Parsippany, New Jersey

9.5
Overall
9.5
Quality
8.5
Value
10
Warranty

GAF holds the #1 market position in North American residential roofing. Their Timberline series is the best-selling shingle line in America, trusted by millions of homeowners.

Industry-leading warranties including WindProven with no speed limit
LayerLock technology for superior wind resistance
Widest contractor network and certification program
Timberline HDZTimberline Ultra HDZTimberline AS IITimberline CS+4 more
8 shingle products in databaseView full profile
GCP Applied Technologies (Grace) logo

GCP Applied Technologies (Grace)

Founded 1854Cambridge, Massachusetts

9.5
Overall
10
Quality
7
Value
9
Warranty

GCP/Grace is the premium leader in ice and water shield products. Many professionals refuse to use any other brand for critical waterproofing applications.

Industry gold standard for ice and water protection
Superior adhesion that self-seals around nails
Proven track record over decades
Grace Ice & Water ShieldGrace Ice & Water Shield HTGrace UltraGrace Tri-Flex XT
0 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Carlisle SynTec logo

Carlisle SynTec

Founded 1960Carlisle, Pennsylvania

9.5
Overall
9.5
Quality
8
Value
9.5
Warranty

Carlisle is the #1 manufacturer of single-ply roofing in North America. Their Sure-Weld TPO and Sure-Seal EPDM are industry standards for commercial and flat roofing applications.

#1 single-ply manufacturer in North America
Industry-leading warranties up to 30 years
Extensive product line for all applications
Sure-Weld TPOSure-Seal EPDMSure-Flex PVCFleeceBACK Membranes
0 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Sika Sarnafil logo

Sika Sarnafil

Founded 1962Canton, Massachusetts

9.5
Overall
10
Quality
7
Value
9.5
Warranty

Sika Sarnafil is the premium leader in PVC roofing with the longest performance track record. Their membranes are specified for the most demanding commercial and institutional projects.

Inventor of PVC roofing (60+ year track record)
Exceptional chemical resistance
Premium quality and durability
Sarnafil G PVCSarnafil S PVCSikaplan TPOSika Sarnafil Decor
0 shingle products in databaseView full profile
CertainTeed logo

CertainTeed

Founded 1904Malvern, Pennsylvania

9.4
Overall
9.5
Quality
8
Value
9
Warranty

CertainTeed is the #2 shingle manufacturer by volume and is often considered to have the best reputation among roofing professionals for consistent quality and extensive product selection.

Largest selection of colors (21+ for Landmark)
Best designer/luxury shingle options
StreakFighter algae resistance technology
LandmarkLandmark PROLandmark PremiumLandmark TL+5 more
7 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Owens Corning logo

Owens Corning

Founded 1938Toledo, Ohio

9.3
Overall
9.5
Quality
8.5
Value
9
Warranty

Owens Corning is the #2 residential roofing manufacturer in North America. They are particularly strong in the retail market through partnerships with Home Depot and Lowe's.

Patented SureNail Technology for superior nail pull-through resistance
Triple Layer Protection in nailing zone
StreakGuard algae protection technology
DurationDuration FLEXDuration StormDuration MAX+4 more
4 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Firestone Building Products logo

Firestone Building Products

Founded 1980Indianapolis, Indiana

9
Overall
9.5
Quality
8
Value
9
Warranty

Firestone is the inventor and leading manufacturer of EPDM roofing. Their RubberGard EPDM is the most specified EPDM membrane in the world with over 8 billion square feet installed.

Inventor of EPDM rubber roofing
Longest field-proven EPDM track record
8+ billion sq ft of EPDM installed globally
RubberGard EPDMUltraPly TPOUltraPly PVCAPP Modified Bitumen
0 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Malarkey Roofing Products logo

Malarkey Roofing Products

Founded 1956Portland, Oregon

8.8
Overall
9
Quality
8
Value
8.5
Warranty

Malarkey is a regional leader, particularly strong in the Western United States. They are known for pioneering SBS (Styrene-Butadiene-Styrene) polymer-modified asphalt shingles.

Class 4 impact resistance on Legacy line
NEX polymer-modified (rubberized) asphalt technology
Environmentally conscious - uses upcycled materials
LegacyLegacy XLVista ARHighlander AR+2 more
4 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Atlas Roofing Corporation logo

Atlas Roofing Corporation

Founded 1982Atlanta, Georgia

8.5
Overall
8.5
Quality
9
Value
8.5
Warranty

Atlas is a value-oriented manufacturer offering quality comparable to premium brands at competitive prices. They are particularly strong in the Southeast and humid coastal regions.

3M Scotchgard protection for superior algae resistance
Core4 technology for enhanced durability
Class 4 impact rating on StormMaster line
Pinnacle PristineStormMaster ShakeStormMaster SlateLegend+1 more
2 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Johns Manville logo

Johns Manville

Founded 1858Denver, Colorado

8.5
Overall
9
Quality
8.5
Value
8.5
Warranty

Johns Manville offers a complete roofing system approach with TPO, EPDM, PVC, and modified bitumen. Known for quality insulation products that pair with their membrane systems.

Berkshire Hathaway financial backing
Over 160 years in business
Complete roofing system solutions
TPO RoofTrakEPDM RoofTrakPVC Membrane SystemsSBS Modified Bitumen
0 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Duro-Last logo

Duro-Last

Founded 1978Saginaw, Michigan

8.5
Overall
9
Quality
8
Value
9
Warranty

Duro-Last dominates the prefabricated roofing market with custom-manufactured membrane systems that arrive ready to install. Ideal for retrofit and re-roofing applications.

Custom prefabricated membranes
Reduced installation time and labor
Excellent for retrofits
Duro-Last PVCDuro-Last EV PVCDuro-Tuff PVCDuro-Last TPO
0 shingle products in databaseView full profile
IKO Industries logo

IKO Industries

Founded 1951Calgary, Canada (North American HQ)

8
Overall
8
Quality
9
Value
7.5
Warranty

IKO is a major international player offering competitive pricing. They have improved quality significantly in recent years after addressing earlier manufacturing issues.

ArmourZone technology on Dynasty line for wind resistance
FastLock sealant for quick adhesion
Competitive pricing across all lines
CambridgeDynastyNordicCrowne Slate+2 more
4 shingle products in databaseView full profile
Versico Roofing Systems logo

Versico Roofing Systems

Founded 1993Carlisle, Pennsylvania

8
Overall
8.5
Quality
9
Value
8
Warranty

Versico is positioned as the value-oriented brand under the Carlisle umbrella, offering quality single-ply membranes at competitive prices with excellent contractor programs.

Backed by Carlisle manufacturing
Competitive pricing
Excellent contractor support
VersiWeld TPOVersiGard EPDMVersiWeld Flex PVC
0 shingle products in databaseView full profile
TAMKO Building Products logo

TAMKO Building Products

Founded 1944Joplin, Missouri

7.8
Overall
7.5
Quality
9
Value
8
Warranty

TAMKO is positioned as a value brand offering good quality at affordable prices. They are particularly strong in the Midwest and Southern regions.

Titan XT has industry-leading 160 mph wind warranty
Excellent value for budget-conscious homeowners
Strong impact resistance on premium lines
HeritageHeritage PremiumHeritage VintageTitan XT+2 more
2 shingle products in databaseView full profile

Can't Decide?

Use our comparison tool to see how different brands stack up for your specific needs and climate.

Compare Brands

Trademark Notice: All brand names, logos, and trademarks mentioned on this page are the property of their respective owners. GAF®, Owens Corning®, CertainTeed®, Malarkey®, Atlas®, IKO®, TAMKO®, and Grace® are registered trademarks of their respective companies. RoofVista is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any of these manufacturers. The information provided is for educational purposes only.View full trademark policy →